The other day I heard the news that the NFL’s San Diego
Chargers had fired their head coach, Marty Schottenheimer. From the reports
that I read, there had been a power struggle between Schottenheimer and
Chargers’ General Manager A.J. Smith, and team President and owner Dean Spanos
decided to keep the GM and dump the Coach.
Never mind that Marty had the best record in the NFL last
year at 14-2 and had chalked up a respectable 47-35 record over the past five
years with the team (an impressive 35-13 during the last three years). Never
mind that Marty is one of only five coaches in NFL history with 200 wins on his
resume (200-126-1), or that the teams he led took the AFC West championship 2
of the last 3 years. Spanos bought into the big lie that MS couldn’t “win the
big one” and unceremoniously fired a hall of fame bound coach because of the
“dysfunctional relationship” between Schottenheimer and Smith.
This, folks, is what the Reverend calls “bad business” and,
in the long run, bad business will net you bad mojo. Let’s analyze, shall we?
On an NFL football team, the General Manager is ostensibly the coach’s boss,
but in reality, it depends a lot on the people involved. The GM has a lot of
say in the talent that is drafted or acquired through trades, working with the
coaching staff and the coaches to put together the best team possible. The GM
has the unenviable position of negotiating with player’s agents on deals and
keeping the team under the league’s salary cap. The GM often also has to play
the heavy, getting rid of non-productive or out-of-their-prime players and he
takes the heat when a superstar leaves the team because there’s no money in the
till to pay their obscene wages.
The team coach, on the other hand, is the engine that makes
the team run. The coach has the responsibility to pull together a staff of
coaches and coordinators that will work together to train and motivate the
players to win. Although the coach certainly has input in player decisions made
by the GM, especially on draft day, often times the coach is the one that has
to make the best out of the player roster that he is given. The coach has the
final say on game day, often calls the plays (or approves them), motivates the
players and makes the final decision when the chips are on the line. Yes,
winning coaches get paid a heck of a lot, especially in comparison to
working-class louts like your humble scribe. But they’re usually the first or
second body out of the door if a team doesn’t win, and they take their lumps
from every amateur coach-wannabe calling their local afternoon sports talk show
to gripe.
As I said above, getting rid of Schottenheimer was just
plain bad business, an egg-headed move by an otherwise smart team executive.
Yes, Marty had trouble “winning the big one,” but that’s really just an epitaph
created by the sports media because they don’t have anything smarter to say and
they don’t want to bore readers with the truth. The truth in the NFL is that 32
teams start the season, but only one wins the Super Bowl Championship. Fact. Yes,
in spite of Schottenheimer’s impressive career record, his teams were dismal in
post-season play. But there’s always next year and if I had a chunk of an NFL
team, I’d rather place my bet on the coach than on the GM. It’s tough to make
it all the way to the “big show” and a team has to have a lot of breaks, some
good luck and a proper alignment of the stars…or, in the case of the New
England Patriots, make a deal with the devil.
Last year, my beloved Pittsburgh Steelers weren’t the best
team in the NFL, but they got hot at the right time, got a couple of breaks,
and they walked off with a Superbowl victory. Coach Bill Cowher, himself often
criticized for being unable to “win the big one,” finally had his championship
ring and brought the Lombardi Trophy home to Steeltown for the Rooney family
that had supported him for so long. Who did the Steelers beat in the AFC
Championship game to go to the Superbowl? The Indianapolis Colts. The year before, the
Colts were the best team in football
(much like the Chargers this year) and they were beaten in the championship
game then, too. What would have happened if Colts owner Jim Irsay had taken the
San Diego route
and gotten rid of coach Tony Dungy? It’s safe to say that he might not have this
year’s Superbowl victory if he had. Dungy finally won his “big one.”
That’s life in the NFL, you say, and half the teams in the
league have gotten rid of their coaches during the last five years. The
lifespan of an NFL coach is short and proven winners command top dollar. However,
here’s a business reality for you all: as long as the San Diego Chargers were
winning games, the team was going to be successful. Fans may gripe about Marty
not being able to win during post-season, but as long as the team was winning –
and they had a winning record under Marty three years running – all of the
team’s home games were going to be sold out, the LT jerseys were going to fly
off the racks and TV ratings were going to hold strong.
Yes, yes, I hear you saying, “Rev, this is football that
you’re talking about. What the hell does it have to do with music?” I once
again submit that bad business decisions equal bad mojo, which you can define
any way that you want. A few years ago, the auto industry in Detroit
made the bone-headed decision that U.S. consumers wanted trucks and
sports utility vehicles instead of gas-effective automobiles. It’s the same
damn stupid logic they used during the late-70s to tout large, expensive,
gas-guzzling cars when smaller, cheaper Japanese imports were beginning to eat Detroit’s lunch in the
market. It almost ruined the American auto industry and it caused many changes
in the decade to follow.
Today, nearly 30 years later, Detroit’s
auto industry is on the brink of extinction and Detroit’s “Big 3” companies are in disarray.
Ford lost over $12 billion last year, General Motors lost $3.9 billion and
Chrysler, reportedly placed on sale by its parent company, lost almost $1.5
billion last year. Because of bad business decisions, Detroit has dropped 50% of the market over
the last 20 years. Over 70,000 industry jobs have been lost during the last
couple of years, with thousands more to fall to the axe in 2007.
So what does this have to do with music? The recording
industry has made its share of bad business decisions during the last few
years. Since 2003, on behalf of its member labels, the RIAA has filed lawsuits
against nearly 20,000 consumers, angering the greater number of record buyers.
The industry has ignored or fought changes in technology that might have
propelled it to greater sales heights over the next decade. They have tried to
foist expensive and unneeded formats on the consumer (can you say DVD-Audio?).
Worst of all, the industry has treated its workers (the musicians) like so much
chattel, cheating them out of royalties even while proclaiming their concern
for the artists with every self-serving press release. This ruse has been
revealed as so much bullshit, with the Internet throwing back the covers and
revealing many of the industry’s dirty little secrets.
Today the recording industry stands at the abyss and it’s
having a lot of trouble figuring out what’s staring back at them when they look
into the future. Bad business decisions have alienated consumers, produced
crappy music and cheated the artists and, as a result, overall music sales have
suffered. The industry is not nearly in the dire straits that they would have
us believe, as billions of dollars in music is still being sold every year.
However, if they continue making bad decisions, the potential for
self-destruction is there. As industry execs ponder technological subjects that
they don’t understand (like DRM) and quibble with other media companies over
payments for intellectual property, they stand at a crossroads…and there’s a
bad mojo risin’.